Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
gfx gfx
76726 Posts in 13480 Topics by 1752 Members - Latest Member: bumm13 March 25, 2023, 11:31:47 am
WinMX World :: Forum  |  Discussion  |  WinMx World News  |  ‘Pirate’ Admins Sweat As ICE Reveal Extradition Criteria

Author Topic: ‘Pirate’ Admins Sweat As ICE Reveal Extradition Criteria  (Read 621 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline DaBees-Knees

  • WMW Team
  • *****

Last month it was revealed that the UK-based admin of is fighting an extradition request filed by the US government. The site’s domain was seized as part of Operation in Our Sites but according to new comments from ICE, more individuals could now be sought by US authorities. Cutting through jurisdictional issues, ICE say they only need to show one thing to seek extradition of an admin – that his or her ‘pirate’ site has a .COM or .NET domain.

One of the very first domain names to be seized by US authorities as part of Operation in Our Sites was that of the very popular It was seized in mid-2010, a move which triggered off dozens more seizures in the months that followed.

Last month, however, it became clear that ICE and DHS had not simply forgotten about the site. They had homed in on Richard O’Dwyer, a computer science undergraduate studying at a university in the north of England. Originally from Chesterfield, the 23-year-old now stands accused of being the administrator of TVShack and the US authorities want him extradited to the US to face trial.

The seemingly global nature of Operation in Our Sites is causing a jurisdiction-bending headache for onlookers, one which is putting immense pressure on O’Dwyer himself. Despite being a UK citizen, despite his site being very similar to TV-Links, a site already cleared by the UK courts as operating legally, and despite TVShack running on a non-stateside server, US authorities say O’Dwyer has broken the law there.

So on what grounds do ICE and DHS feel they can prosecute O’Dwyer and others like him around the world, individuals who are clearly outside US jurisdiction? Simple – they operate a domain name operated from inside the United States.

“The jurisdiction we have over these sites right now really is the use of the domain name registry system in the United States. That’s the key,” says ICE assistant deputy director Erik Barnett speaking with The Guardian.

The only necessary “nexus to the US” is a .COM or .NET domain for which Verisign acts as the official registry operator, Barnett added.

The fact that Verisign-operated domains are prime targets for seizure by US authorities was highlighted in our earlier article, but that operating one should now provide grounds for site owners to be extradited to the United States is an unsettling development.

From earlier cases, such as the one involving the OiNK BitTorrent tracker, it became clear that hosting a site overseas did not save a UK admin from prosecution. Nevertheless, there are plenty of UK-based site operators who host their sites in relatively friendly locales such as Canada and do so relatively unhindered.

However, the ground appears to be slowly shifting under their feet. Time and again its been shown that WHOIS protection services can be bypassed by determined US-based entertainment company lawyers. Even if real identities can’t be obtained this way the MPAA-backed Federation Against Copyright Theft has enough standing with the UK police to obtain the real identities of site operators should they so desire, without the complication or expense of instigating a civil lawsuit.

Once the authorities have an identity, all options seem to be open.

Of course, ICE isn’t restricting itself only to the UK – anyone with a .NET or .COM extension could become a target – but with its US-friendly extradition agreement, things could heat up there very quickly.

"the MPAA-backed Federation Against Copyright Theft has enough standing with the UK police to obtain the real identities of site operators "

So the MPAA has a very cosy arrangement with the UK police! A few questions need asking about this arrangement.  :gum:

Offline GhostShip

  • Ret. WinMX Special Forces
  • WMW Team
  • *****
Re: ‘Pirate’ Admins Sweat As ICE Reveal Extradition Criteria
« Reply #1 on: July 04, 2011, 09:45:10 pm »
A few questions are already being asked at governmental level, there are plans to change the terms of the fairly recently negotiated extradition arrangement with the US and also European law courts are likely to state the humans rights act trumps arbitrary and quasi legal claims of jurisdiction over EU bloc nationals, the article above also fails to state that although the operator of Oink was brought to court he was cleared of all charges thus the misleading mention of his case shows theres a lot of hot air and little substance in this.

WinMX World :: Forum  |  Discussion  |  WinMx World News  |  ‘Pirate’ Admins Sweat As ICE Reveal Extradition Criteria

©2005-2023 All Rights Reserved.
SMF 2.0.19 | SMF © 2021, Simple Machines | Terms and Policies
Page created in 0.025 seconds with 23 queries.
Helios Multi © Bloc
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!