Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
gfx gfx
76778 Posts in 13501 Topics by 1650 Members - Latest Member: insider4ever June 24, 2024, 12:35:09 pm
WinMX World :: Forum  |  Discussion  |  WinMx World News  |  File-sharing student fights fine

Author Topic: File-sharing student fights fine  (Read 546 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline DaBees-Knees

  • WMW Team
  • *****
File-sharing student fights fine
« on: January 05, 2010, 01:39:54 pm »

A US student who was fined $675,000 (£421,000) for illegally downloading music has asked a judge to reduce the damages or offer him a retrial.

Joel Tenenbaum said that the costs awarded were "grossly excessive".

The court case focused on 30 tracks that Mr Tenenbaum admitted downloading. He was fined $22,500 per song.

The court admitted that initially the market for online music was "unfair" because there were not many legal alternative to illegal downloads.

The case, between Sony BMG and Mr Tenenbaum, was one of the first to acknowledge that consumers did not have much choice in the early days of digital music.

But Mr Tenenbaum was fined more heavily because some of his downloading activities were detected after Apple established its iTunes store, the court said.

Mr Tenenbaum is working with internet lawyer Charles Nesson.

In his motion filed to the Massachusetts District Court, Mr Nesson argues that the fact that iTunes music was initially restricted by Digital Rights Management software made it "less appealing" than illegal DRM-free alternatives.

"The court ignored the impact encryption had on the fairness of music consumers' choice.

"Tenenbaum and all other music listeners could not get exactly the songs they wanted, in exactly the format they wanted until the industry giants changed their position in 2007," he added.

As such he argues that "the Court should substantially reduce the bankrupting...award against Tenenbaum".

Under US law, recording companies can claim up to $30,000 per infringement although the jury can raise the amount to $150,000 if it finds the infringements were wilful.

Although his trial focused on 30 tracks, Mr Tenenbaum admitted downloading more than 800 songs since 1999.

After the trial, supporters began to donate money to Mr Tenenbaum but he refused it.

"I ask no-one to help me. And I ask for no-one to cover what I signed up for," he said at the time.

I wish him luck. Excessive fines seem to be the norm where the recording industry is concerned. How the courts can justify such large fines has yet to be explained.  :gum:

Offline Trestor

  • Forum Member
  • Your call is important to us ...
Re: File-sharing student fights fine
« Reply #1 on: January 05, 2010, 02:23:21 pm »
Haven't we been told before that the only people who have been prosecuted were those who have Uploaded and none who have Downloaded? Or am I having a memory failure?

WinMX World :: Forum  |  Discussion  |  WinMx World News  |  File-sharing student fights fine

©2005-2024 All Rights Reserved.
SMF 2.0.19 | SMF © 2021, Simple Machines | Terms and Policies
Page created in 0.023 seconds with 24 queries.
Helios Multi © Bloc
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!